德军吧 关注:236,392贴子:2,616,998

【笑谈】三炮又一“大作”

只看楼主收藏回复

苏军吧吧务红三炮,转战知乎,怒拍苏德伤亡比1:1.4,令听者流泪,无知者害怕的真相居然是!
一楼召唤巨龙,吞噬无知之人



IP属地:云南来自Android客户端1楼2017-03-09 15:31回复
    我们先来看看文豪取得OVERMAN的数据吧,大家都知道OM的数据一直在更,且带夸大和吹水,一直不为德国官方和各国所承认,OM自己也表示了这一点。
    于是乎
    Statistics for German World War II military casualties are divergent and contradictory. The wartime military casualty figures compiled by German High Command, up until January 31, 1945, are often cited by military historians when covering individual campaigns in the war. A recent study by the German historianRüdiger Overmansfound that the German High Command statistics are not reliable, he estimated German military dead at 5.3 million, including 900,000 men conscripted from outside of Germany's 1937 borders, in Austria, and in east-central Europe.[1][2][3]However the German government still maintains that its records list 4.3 million dead and missing military personnel.[4][5]Civilian deaths during the war include air raid deaths, estimates of German civilians killed only by Allied strategic bombing have ranged from around 350,000[6][7]to 500,000.[8][9][10][11][12]Civilian deaths, due to theflight and expulsion of Germansand theforced labor of Germans in the Soviet Unionare disputed and range from 500,000[13][14][15]to over 2.0 million.[16][17][18]According to the German government Suchdienste (Search Service) there were 300,000 German victims (including Jews) of Nazi racial, political and religious persecution.[19]This statistic does not include 200,000 German persons with mental and/or physical disabilities who were murdered in theNazi euthanasia program
    文豪就他喵的取了个最大值定义为德军伤亡
    然后和苏军的最低伤亡比(不知道是数学不好还是为了给德棍面子,算出来是1:1.6,不愧是文豪,本着以“事实”为真相压低了0.3的比例,德意志三代人皆该感谢文豪不杀之恩。


    IP属地:云南来自Android客户端4楼2017-03-09 15:45
    回复
      而可笑的是,1974年苏联自己的一份资料宣称1945年苏消灭了100万德军,考虑到苏毛冷战期间资料的可靠性和该统计已经包括德军当年1月损失,并把之前的战俘全部计算为不可恢复损失来计算,则德军以指挥链传递上去的总损失应当略低于300万。
      当然同那些质疑以指挥链传递上去统计存在大量缺失的俄国学者一样,Overman也认为应当利用Deutsche Dienststelle (WASt)(has been responsible for providing information for the families of those military personnel who were killed or went missing in the war.)的数据来进行统计调查,这一数据本质上和俄罗斯国防部档案馆那份利用逐个士兵卡片进行统计的统计方式是一样的。
      overman所给出的数字被认为是偏高估了(由于人手和经费限制他采用的是抽检,抽了近5000张卡片,而不是苏俄国防部档案馆对应部门那样丧心病狂的逐家调查加六七十年来不断的修正。


      IP属地:云南来自Android客户端5楼2017-03-09 15:48
      收起回复
        SY强身,YY强国,红三炮这也算YY吧!不知道强了什么


        IP属地:上海来自Android客户端6楼2017-03-09 16:28
        回复
          何必呢~何必为了这种人占用学习时间呢~开心女王好好复习


          IP属地:河北来自Android客户端7楼2017-03-09 18:15
          回复
            文豪从过年到妇女节 这一个多月的时间一直都在拜师学艺和整理资料


            IP属地:澳大利亚来自Android客户端8楼2017-03-09 18:37
            收起回复
              看看乌克兰那些国家男女比例就知道咯。德国人注水。。开玩笑,这个世界上如果只有一个认真,负责谨慎到刻薄的民族,那就是日耳曼人了。青岛下水系统就是德国人修的,前些年,设备部件需要更换,这么多年过去了,然而德国人还在背这个锅。


              来自iPhone客户端13楼2017-03-10 03:22
              收起回复
                谎报人头两边都有,不过对苏战争里双方人头比要是能到1:1.4
                加上轴心国别国军队,KD比岂不反超?对此我的解释是这个数据是对的,绝对交换比差不多1:1,德军把战后把古拉格和西伯利亚的叛徒也算进苏军英雄队伍里了
                正经点,苏军把死在战俘营里德军算一次人头加上俘虏他们算一次,估计就达到了1:1.4了


                IP属地:江苏来自Android客户端14楼2017-03-10 11:28
                收起回复
                  小白日常看不懂


                  IP属地:广东来自Android客户端15楼2017-03-10 11:47
                  回复
                    本苏粉 不信这个1比1.4的。


                    IP属地:四川17楼2017-03-10 17:20
                    收起回复
                      我不晓得你们双方在说啥,看戏抱图就好了


                      IP属地:澳大利亚来自Android客户端18楼2017-03-10 18:27
                      回复
                        不是3:7吗??


                        IP属地:河南19楼2017-03-10 18:59
                        收起回复